How the modern appeals system works
Before 2019, disagreeing with a VA decision usually meant joining a single, slow appeals line that could stretch on for years. The Veterans Appeals Improvement and Modernization Act of 2017, usually called the Appeals Modernization Act or AMA, replaced that line with three separate "lanes." For VA decisions issued on or after February 19, 2019, you generally choose one lane for each issue you want reviewed.
The idea behind the lanes is simple: different problems call for different fixes. If your claim was denied because something was missing, you can add evidence. If the evidence was already there but the decision-maker got it wrong, you can ask a more senior reviewer to take a fresh look. And if you want an independent judge to decide, you can go to the Board of Veterans' Appeals.
A few features of the AMA system are worth keeping in mind from the start:
- One lane at a time per issue. You generally cannot have the same issue pending in two lanes at once, but different issues from the same decision can go to different lanes.
- You can move between lanes. If one review doesn't go your way, you can usually choose another lane afterward, as long as you act within the deadline.
- Your effective date can be protected. Filing the next review on time generally keeps the original effective date intact, which can matter a great deal for back pay.
- Decision letters must explain themselves. VA decision notices are required to identify the issues decided, summarize the evidence considered, and note any favorable findings. Those favorable findings are generally binding in later reviews unless rebutted by clear and convincing evidence.
Every claim has its own history and evidence. This page explains the system in general terms; the right lane for your issue depends on the facts in your file.
Your review options
Select a lane below to see what it involves, which form starts it, and when it may make sense.
Supplemental Claim (VA Form 20-0995)
A Supplemental Claim asks VA to decide the issue again with evidence it did not have before. The key requirement is new and relevant evidence: "new" means VA has not already considered it, and "relevant" means it tends to prove or disprove something that matters to the claim. A fresh medical opinion linking your condition to service, updated treatment records, or a statement from someone who served with you are common examples. Unless you are relying on a change in the law, the application is generally not complete without it.
Because this is a claim-level lane, VA's duty to assist applies. If you identify relevant records, such as VA medical center files, other federal records, or private treatment records you authorize VA to request (usually with VA Form 21-4142), VA generally must make reasonable efforts to obtain them. VA may also schedule a new examination.
Often considered when
- The denial pointed to a missing piece, such as no current diagnosis or no medical link to service.
- You have new records, a private medical opinion, or lay statements to add.
- A law change, such as a new presumption, may now apply to your condition.
Higher-Level Review (VA Form 20-0996)
A Higher-Level Review asks a more experienced adjudicator, who was not involved in the prior decision, to take a new look at the same evidence. You cannot add new evidence in this lane. The reviewer decides the issue fresh (de novo) and can change the outcome based on a difference of opinion or on an error in the earlier decision, including a clear and unmistakable error.
You may request one informal conference: a phone call in which you or your representative can point the reviewer to specific errors in the file. It is not a hearing, and new evidence cannot be submitted during it. VA notes that requesting a conference may lengthen the review, and that the reviewer generally makes two attempts to reach you before deciding without the call.
If the reviewer finds that VA failed in its duty to assist before the prior decision, for example by not requesting identified records or relying on an inadequate exam, the reviewer generally returns the issue so VA can correct the error and issue a new decision, unless the claim can be granted in full on the existing record.
Often considered when
- The favorable evidence was already in the file but appears to have been overlooked or misread.
- The rating criteria seem to have been applied incorrectly.
- VA skipped a required step, like obtaining records you identified.
Board Appeal (VA Form 10182, Notice of Disagreement)
A Board Appeal sends your issue to the Board of Veterans' Appeals in Washington, D.C., where a Veterans Law Judge decides it. The Board is part of VA but separate from the regional offices that make initial decisions. On the Notice of Disagreement you choose one of three dockets:
- Direct Review. The judge reviews the evidence that was before VA at the time of the decision. No new evidence and no hearing. VA describes this as the fastest Board option.
- Evidence Submission. No hearing, but you may submit new evidence with your Notice of Disagreement or within 90 days after the Board receives it.
- Hearing. You testify before a Veterans Law Judge by virtual tele-hearing from your own device, by videoconference from a VA location near you, or in person at the Board in Washington, D.C. (at your own travel cost). You may submit new evidence at the hearing or within 90 days after it.
In some circumstances you may be able to change dockets after filing, generally within a limited window and before submitting evidence or testimony. If the Board finds a duty-to-assist error, it generally remands the issue to the regional office for correction.
Often considered when
- You want an independent judge's decision, especially on complex legal or medical questions.
- Your credibility matters and you would like to explain your situation in your own words.
- Earlier reviews did not resolve the dispute.
Comparing the lanes
VA publishes average processing goals for each option. These are targets, not promises, and actual times vary by issue, workload and whether additional development is needed.
| Lane | New evidence? | Who decides | Hearing? | VA's stated average goal |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Supplemental Claim | Yes, required (new and relevant) | VA claims adjudicator | No | About 125 days |
| Higher-Level Review | No | Senior VA reviewer | No (optional informal conference call) | About 125 days |
| Board – Direct Review | No | Veterans Law Judge | No | About 365 days |
| Board – Evidence Submission | Yes, within 90 days of filing | Veterans Law Judge | No | About 550 days |
| Board – Hearing | Yes, at or within 90 days after the hearing | Veterans Law Judge | Yes | About 730 days |
Goals shown are those VA lists on its decision review pages for non-healthcare benefits as of this page's review date. Check va.gov for current figures.
Deadlines and your effective date
The effective date is the date from which VA pays benefits once a claim is granted. In many cases it is tied to when you first filed. Keeping a claim in "continuous pursuit," meaning you file each next step on time, generally lets you preserve that original date even if it takes several reviews to get the right result.
- After an initial decision
You generally have one year from the date on the decision notice to file a Supplemental Claim, request a Higher-Level Review, or file a Board Appeal.
- After a Supplemental Claim or Higher-Level Review decision
You generally have another year to choose a next step: a Supplemental Claim, a Higher-Level Review (after a Supplemental Claim decision; you cannot request a second HLR of an HLR decision), or a Board Appeal.
- After a Board decision
You may file a Supplemental Claim within one year to keep continuous pursuit, or appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims within 120 days of the date on the Board's decision.
- After a Court decision
Filing a Supplemental Claim within one year of a final Court decision can also generally preserve the effective date.
Missing a one-year window does not always end your ability to seek benefits, but it can cost you your earlier effective date and the back pay attached to it. The 120-day Court deadline is shorter, and contested claims (for example, where two people claim the same benefit) have a 60-day window for a Board Appeal. Count from the date printed on your decision letter, not the date you received it, and file well before the last day.
If you can't file a complete review in time, talk to someone promptly. There are limited ways to address missed deadlines, such as showing good cause for an extension in certain circumstances, but they should not be relied upon.
The Court and beyond
The U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (CAVC) is a federal court that is independent of VA. It reviews final Board decisions for legal error based on the record that was before the Board; it does not take new evidence or hold a new trial. The notice of appeal is filed with the Court itself, not with VA, generally within 120 days of the date on the Board decision.
Many Court cases are resolved when the parties agree that the Board made an error and jointly ask the Court to send the case back for a new Board decision. Decisions of the CAVC can in turn be appealed, on limited legal questions, to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit and, rarely, to the Supreme Court.
A note on legacy appeals
Appeals of decisions issued before February 19, 2019 may still be in the older "legacy" system, which uses Notices of Disagreement filed with the regional office, Statements of the Case and VA Form 9 appeals. Some legacy appellants were able to opt into the AMA system. If you have an older appeal still pending, its rules and options can differ from what is described above.
Which path may fit
These examples are general illustrations of how veterans and their representatives often think about the lanes. They are not recommendations for your case.
"VA said there was no nexus."
If the denial turned on the lack of a medical opinion connecting your condition to service, a Supplemental Claim with a well-reasoned private opinion is a common route.
About DBQs →"The proof was already there."
If favorable records were in your file but the decision didn't address them, a Higher-Level Review, with an informal conference to point them out, may be worth considering.
Higher-Level Review →"They need to hear my story."
When the outcome depends on your account of events or symptoms, the Board's hearing docket lets you speak directly to a judge and add evidence afterward.
Board Appeal →"The C&P exam missed the point."
An inadequate exam may support a duty-to-assist argument in a Higher-Level Review, or it can be countered with new medical evidence in a Supplemental Claim or Board evidence docket.
C&P exam guide →How our firm helps
Decision reviews and appeals are the center of our practice. Our founder, Juan Cortés, is a former attorney at the Board of Veterans' Appeals, and that experience shapes how we read a file and prepare a case. Our work typically includes:
- Requesting your claims file (C-file) so we see exactly what VA saw.
- Reviewing the record and decision to identify factual, medical and legal errors, as well as favorable findings to preserve.
- Recommending a lane for each issue, with the reasons and trade-offs explained.
- Developing evidence, including treatment records, lay and buddy statements, and employment information.
- Coordinating independent medical opinions where a qualified clinician's view may address a gap.
- Preparing you for a Board hearing so you know what to expect and can testify clearly.
- Writing briefs and arguments for reviewers and Veterans Law Judges, tied to the evidence and the law.
- Tracking every deadline to help protect continuous pursuit and your effective date.
We offer free, virtual consultations to veterans across the country. For eligible matters, fees are success-based, and VA-accredited attorneys generally may charge fees only after VA has issued an initial decision. No attorney can promise a particular outcome.
Official sources
- VA.gov – Decision reviews and appeals
- VA.gov – Supplemental Claims
- VA.gov – Higher-Level Reviews
- VA.gov – Board Appeals
- Board of Veterans' Appeals
- 38 CFR Part 3, Subpart D – Universal adjudication rules (incl. §§ 3.2500–3.2601)
- 38 CFR Part 20 – Board of Veterans' Appeals: Rules of Practice
- U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims
Reviewed November 2026. Laws and VA procedures change; confirm current rules before relying on this information.